Waiting days for a review wears you down. These pull request best practices help: keep changes small, explain the why, review your own diff first, and let automation handle style.
Pull requests are one slice of wider software development best practices, and a few habits here pay off on every team.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Average PR size in the faster-shipping teams | 50 lines of code |
| PR size in the comparison teams | More than 200 lines |
| Extra code shipped by the smaller-PR teams | 40% more |
| Review cycles per PR, best teams | 1.1 cycles |
| Review cycles per PR, typical teams | 1.2 cycles |
| Suggested maximum length of one review | Under one hour |
These figures come from a Mergify guide dated 05 Feb 2025. They can change, so check the source before you rely on them.
Keep pull requests small and focused
A good pull request does one job. GitHub’s guidance says to aim for small, focused pull requests that fulfil a single purpose, because smaller pull requests are easier and faster to review and merge, leave less room to introduce bugs, and provide a clearer history of changes.
Size also shows up in the numbers. The Mergify guide dated 05 Feb 2025 reports that teams with PRs averaging 50 lines of code ship 40% more code than teams whose PRs exceed 200 lines. Treat that as one data point rather than a rule, since team context varies.
When a change is big, split it before you open anything:
- Map out the key steps and the natural break points.
- Create a separate branch for each component and work on them independently.
- Submit the pull requests in a logical sequence that builds toward the full feature.
Mergify gives an example: for user authentication, use separate PRs for database schema updates, API endpoints and frontend components. The same guide warns that too many tiny PRs make it hard to see the full picture, so aim for atomic changes that still deliver clear value.
Write a description reviewers can act on
Reviewers should grasp your change in seconds. GitHub recommends clear titles and descriptions so reviewers can quickly understand what the pull request does, and its guidance on what to include in the body is short enough to copy.
- The purpose of the pull request.
- An overview of what changed.
- Links to extra context, such as tracking issues or earlier conversations.
Tell reviewers what kind of feedback you want: a quick look or a deeper critique. If the change touches many files, say where to start and in what order to read them. GitHub’s newer documentation adds that you can use issue-closing keywords when a pull request should close an issue after merging.

Review your own pull request first
Before anyone else sees it, read your own diff. GitHub advises you to review, build, and test your own pull request before submitting it, which catches the typos and slips that reviewers would otherwise spend time on.
A self-review can include reading the diff, checking for accidental changes, and making sure relevant builds or tests have run. Running your own change through a code review checklist makes this step repeatable.
Readability counts too. Following shared naming conventions in programming keeps a diff easy to scan.
Give security a pass as well. GitHub’s documentation says this matters most when a pull request changes dependencies, authentication, permissions, workflows, or code that handles sensitive data.
Let templates, owners and automation do the routine work
If you maintain a repository, standardise the process so good habits do not rely on memory. GitHub’s maintainer guidance, taken from an archived Enterprise Server edition of its docs, lists four tools worth setting up:
- Pull request templates customise and standardise the information contributors include. They can carry a task list of things to finish before merging.
- Code owners are automatically requested for review when a pull request modifies files they own.
- Protected branches stop merges into important branches such as main until conditions are met, for example passing CI tests or an approving review.
- Linters and other automated tools keep styling consistent and understandable.
The last item frees people up. GitHub notes that catching smaller problems like typos or styling leaves more time for reviewers to focus on the substance of a pull request. Mergify makes the same point about linters, formatters and test runners flagging issues before a human looks.
How do you keep reviews moving?
Speed comes from visible status and sensible limits. GitHub suggests that status labels help reviewers understand whether a pull request is ready for review, blocked, or still in progress, so nobody reviews work that is not ready.
Mergify recommends tracking a few metrics rather than guessing:
- PR size, to encourage bite-sized changes.
- Review cycle time, meaning how long it takes from PR creation to merge.
- Number of reviewers, enough to catch issues but not so many that progress stalls.
- Time to first review, since quick initial feedback keeps developers productive.
In the same guide, dated 05 Feb 2025, the best teams average 1.1 review cycles per PR, better than the typical 1.2 cycles. It also suggests aiming to keep reviews under one hour, and breaking large changes into smaller pull requests when they run longer.
Frequently asked questions
How small should a pull request be?
Show answer
GitHub gives no fixed limit; it says to keep each pull request focused on a single purpose. As one data point, the Mergify guide dated 05 Feb 2025 compares PRs averaging 50 lines with those above 200 lines.
Should I review my own pull request?
Show answer
Yes. Reading the diff, building and testing before you submit catches errors that would otherwise cost a reviewer’s time.
What should a pull request description include?
Show answer
State the purpose, summarise what changed, and link related issues or earlier conversations. Say what feedback you need and which files to read first.
Do linters replace human reviewers?
Show answer
No. They handle styling and small mistakes so that reviewers can concentrate on design, logic and risk.



